317-488-5500 
Drivers facing a failure to yield ticket with accident in Indiana must understand the critical interplay between traffic violations, license points, and the resulting civil liability for property damage and bodily injury.
The Legal Definition of Failure to Yield in Indiana
A failure to yield citation indicates that a driver did not properly grant the right-of-way to another vehicle, pedestrian, or cyclist as required by law. In Indiana, this traffic violation becomes significantly more serious when it results in a car accident. While a standard ticket might only result in a fine and points, a citation issued at the scene of a crash serves as official documentation of fault. This moves the issue from a simple traffic infraction to a complex legal matter involving insurance claims and potential lawsuits.
Indiana License Points and Administrative Penalties
The Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV) assigns point values to traffic violations, and a failure to yield resulting in an accident typically carries a higher point value than a standard infraction. Accumulating points can lead to administrative penalties, including the suspension of driving privileges. If the accident resulted in serious bodily injury or death, the state may impose an automatic license suspension regardless of the driver’s prior point total. Paying the fine essentially acts as a plea of guilty, ensuring these points are permanently added to the driving record.
The Impact on Insurance Premiums and Coverage
Insurance carriers view a failure to yield ticket with an accident as a major risk indicator, almost invariably leading to a sharp increase in premiums. If the driver is deemed “at fault” due to the citation, their insurance company is responsible for covering the damages of the other party. This payout, combined with the moving violation, places the driver in a “high-risk” category. In severe cases, or if the driver has a history of similar violations, the insurance provider may choose to drop coverage entirely upon policy renewal.
The Ticket as Prima Facie Evidence in Civil Court
The most dangerous aspect of receiving this ticket is its role in civil personal injury lawsuits. If the other party files a claim for medical bills or pain and suffering, the fact that police issued a failure to yield citation can be used as prima facie evidence of negligence. While the ticket itself does not automatically guarantee a loss in civil court, it shifts the burden of proof, making it difficult for the cited driver to argue they were not responsible for the crash. Legal counsel is often required to challenge this presumption of fault.
Understanding Indiana’s Modified Comparative Fault Rule
Indiana operates under a ’modified comparative fault’ system, which bars recovery of damages if a person is found to be 51% or more at fault for an accident. A failure to yield ticket is a strong indicator of being primarily responsible (usually well over 51%). For the driver who received the ticket, this means they are likely barred from receiving compensation for their own injuries. Conversely, for the victim of the accident, this citation is a powerful tool used by attorneys to establish the other driver’s liability and secure a settlement.
Criminal Consequences for Serious Injuries
When a failure to yield accident results in catastrophic injury or death, the situation escalates from a traffic infraction to a potential criminal offense. In Indiana, causing serious bodily injury due to a traffic violation can lead to misdemeanor or even felony charges. These situations require immediate defense to protect against jail time, significant criminal fines, and long-term license revocation. If you are facing such charges, or if you have been injured by a driver who was charged, the stakes are incredibly high.
Immediate Steps to Take at the Accident Scene
Preserving evidence immediately after the crash is vital for disputing a ticket or building an injury claim. This includes taking photographs of vehicle positions before they are moved, documenting skid marks, and securing contact information from witnesses. The determination of “failure to yield” is often subjective based on the officer’s observation of the aftermath; physical evidence can sometimes prove that the other driver was speeding or operating without headlights, which may have contributed to the crash.
How Medical Records Influence the Case
If injuries are involved, medical documentation becomes the centerpiece of any resulting legal action. Seeking immediate medical attention ensures that injuries are directly linked to the accident in official records. Delays in treatment can be used by insurance companies to argue that the injuries were pre-existing or unrelated to the failure to yield incident. Firms like Christie Bell & Marshall, which employs Laura J. Conyers, RN as an attorney-nurse associate, utilize this medical data to accurately value claims and prove the severity of the impact.
Why You Should Not Just Pay the Fine
Simply paying the ticket for failure to yield after an accident is an admission of guilt that can have cascading financial effects. By paying, you may inadvertently waive your right to contest fault in a future lawsuit brought by the other driver. It is often strategic to consult with an attorney to determine if the ticket can be contested or if a plea to a lesser charge is possible, specifically to minimize the impact on civil liability.
Financial Crisis: Uninsured Drivers and Failure to Yield
A critical financial emergency arises when the driver cited for failure to yield lacks valid auto insurance. In Indiana, if the at-fault driver is uninsured, they face personal liability for the total cost of damages and medical bills, which can amount to tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars. For the injured party, this situation necessitates an immediate investigation into their own Uninsured Motorist (UM) coverage. Without this coverage, or if the at-fault driver has no assets, recovering compensation for serious injuries becomes significantly more complex, often requiring specialized legal intervention to identify alternative sources of recovery.
Seeking Legal Help for Injury Victims
If you were the victim hit by a driver who failed to yield, the citation issued to them is the first step in your recovery process. However, insurance companies often attempt to settle these clear-liability cases quickly and for far less than they are worth. An experienced personal injury firm will use the failure to yield citation as leverage to demand full compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. Christie Bell & Marshall has a 30-year track record of success holding negligent drivers accountable in these specific scenarios.
Contacting an Indiana Personal Injury Attorney
Navigating the aftermath of a failure to yield accident requires professional guidance, whether you are defending against liability or seeking compensation for injuries. The team at Christie Bell & Marshall, led by Lee Christie and Tina Bell, specializes in dissecting accident reports and challenging insurance company narratives. If you have been injured, they operate on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay no fees unless a recovery is made.
Contact Christie Bell & Marshall Today for a Free Case Review.
Call 317-488-5500 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form