A patient has a hernia repaired at a surgery center off Michigan Road, and two years later the mesh that was supposed to hold everything in place has shrunk, migrated, and grown into the bowel. The question that follows is harder than most people expect: was the device defective, was it implanted incorrectly, or both? Christie Bell & Marshall answers that question with engineering, medical records, and the device itself, and our Indianapolis product liability attorneys take on manufacturers that have entire legal departments devoted to defending these claims.

Medical device cases sit where product liability law, federal FDA rules, and Indiana’s medical malpractice system meet, and each one has its own deadlines and defenses. Getting the path right early protects the claim. Your consultation is free, and you don’t pay unless your case is won.

How Our Indianapolis Defective Medical Device Lawyers Build the Case Against the Manufacturer

Device cases are won or lost on evidence that is easy to lose, starting with the device itself. These are the steps we take first:

  • Preserving the removed device. When a failed implant is taken out, hospitals often send it to pathology or discard it. We send preservation requests so the device is kept under a documented chain of custody for independent testing.
  • Identifying the exact product. The operative report and implant records list the manufacturer, model, lot number, and unique device identifier, which tell us whether the product has been recalled or the subject of safety warnings.
  • Searching federal safety reports. The FDA’s MAUDE database collects adverse event reports from manufacturers and hospitals, and a pattern of similar failures can show the company knew about the problem.
  • Determining the FDA approval pathway. Whether a device was cleared through the 510(k) process or approved through premarket approval affects which claims are available, so we establish it early.
  • Reviewing the surgical and hospital care. A failure that looks like a defect may involve a surgeon’s choice or technique, and a failure that looks like surgical error may involve the device. We review both before deciding who to pursue.
  • Retaining independent engineers and physicians. Experts in materials, biomedical engineering, and the relevant surgical specialty examine the device and explain how it failed.

We prepare every device file for trial, which matters most against manufacturers that rarely settle early. If you are ready to discuss what happened, a free consultation is the place to start.

Speak with a personal injury lawyer today. Call: 317-488-5500

Common Types of Defective Medical Devices

Medical device failures fall into a few broad groups, and each raises different questions about design, manufacturing, and warnings.

Implants That Fail Inside the Body

Hip and knee replacements that loosen or shed metal debris, spinal hardware that fractures, and surgical mesh that erodes, shrinks, or migrates can require revision surgery and cause lasting harm. Problems with hernia and pelvic mesh have led to some of the largest device litigation in the country.

Cardiac and Implanted Electronic Devices

Pacemakers, defibrillators, and implanted pumps rely on batteries, leads, and software. A defect in any of those parts can cause the device to stop working, deliver the wrong therapy, or fail without warning.

Surgical Instruments and Robotic Systems

Staplers that misfire, energy instruments that cause burns, and robotic systems that malfunction can injure organs and blood vessels during surgery. These cases often overlap with claims of surgical error by the operating team.

Devices Used at Home

Insulin pumps, glucose monitors, breathing machines, and infusion devices can fail in ways patients cannot detect until they cause harm, and some recalls come only after many reports of injury.

Many patients first hear about a problem through a recall letter or a news report about their medical devices. Indianapolis attorneys at Christie Bell & Marshall then work to identify whether the problem began at the factory, in the design, in the warnings, or in the operating room.

Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now

Indiana Product Liability Law, FDA Rules, and Medical Malpractice

The Indiana Product Liability Act

Claims against device manufacturers in Indiana are governed by the Indiana Product Liability Act. A manufacturer can be liable when a device was sold in a defective condition that made it unreasonably dangerous, whether because of a manufacturing flaw, a dangerous design, or inadequate warnings. For design and warning claims, Indiana requires showing that the manufacturer failed to use reasonable care. Warnings for prescription devices are usually directed to the physician, so what the manufacturer told your surgeon becomes a central issue.

Federal Preemption

Some medical devices go through the FDA’s rigorous premarket approval process, and federal law can block many state law claims against those devices unless the claim is based on the manufacturer violating federal requirements. Devices cleared through the more common 510(k) process generally do not receive the same protection. This distinction can decide the case, which is why we confirm the device’s regulatory history before anything else.

Deadlines and the Medical Malpractice Act

Under IC 34-20-3-1, product claims face two clocks: two years from when the claim accrues, and an outer limit of ten years after the device was first delivered to its initial user. If a physician or hospital was also negligent, that part of the claim usually goes through Indiana’s Medical Malpractice Act, which has its own two-year deadline and a medical review panel process. Running both claims on the right schedule is one of the most important things a lawyer does in these cases. To learn which of these rules governs your device, schedule a free consultation.

Click to contact us today

Common Injuries From Defective Medical Devices

Device failures usually happen inside the body, so the injuries are often serious and slow to diagnose:

  • Revision surgeries. Additional operations to remove or replace a failed implant, each with its own risks and recovery.
  • Infection and inflammation. Chronic infections and tissue reactions around failed implants or mesh.
  • Organ perforation and internal bleeding. Damage to the bowel, bladder, or blood vessels from migrating mesh, misfiring staplers, or instrument failures.
  • Metal toxicity. Elevated metal levels in the blood and tissue damage from implants that shed metal debris.
  • Nerve damage and chronic pain. Pain that persists after the device is removed, sometimes permanently.
  • Cardiac events. Dangerous heart rhythms or loss of therapy when a cardiac device fails.
  • Fatal outcomes. A death caused by a failed device gives certain family members a wrongful death claim of their own.

Our team works with treating physicians and independent specialists from the start, so the medical record connects each injury to the device rather than to your underlying condition.

What Compensation Can You Recover for a Defective Medical Device?

Device claims often involve multiple surgeries and years of treatment, and manufacturers defend them aggressively. Compensation can include:

  • Economic damages. The cost of revision surgeries, hospitalization, medication, therapy, and future medical care, plus income you could not earn and any reduced ability to work in the future.
  • Non-economic damages. Pain, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and the fear and frustration of going through surgery again because a product failed.
  • Future medical monitoring and care. Ongoing testing, imaging, and treatment when a failed device leaves lasting damage, including the permanent, lifelong medical care some patients need.
  • Spousal claims. A husband or wife can seek compensation for the companionship and help at home the injury has taken away.
  • Punitive damages. When evidence shows a manufacturer knew about a danger and concealed it or kept selling the device, punitive damages may be available.

Christie Bell & Marshall builds these damages with treating physicians, life care planners, and economists, so the claim reflects the full cost of a device that was supposed to help you.

Do You Have an Indianapolis Defective Medical Device Claim?

Chad J. Bradford is a partner at Christie Bell & Marshall who spent more than 20 years defending physicians, hospitals, and other health care providers, including work as legal counsel for a national healthcare liability insurer. Here is his perspective on device claims in Indianapolis:

“When I defended hospitals, device cases often turned into a finger-pointing match. The manufacturer blamed the surgeon, the surgeon blamed the device, and the patient was caught in the middle. That is exactly why these cases need someone who knows both sides from the beginning. We look at the device, the warnings, and the operating room together, so when a manufacturer says the surgeon used it wrong, we already know whether that is true.”

Do You Qualify?

  • A device implanted or used during your care failed, was recalled, or required removal or revision surgery.
  • You have records identifying the device, or a hospital still has the device that was removed.
  • The failure caused new injuries, additional surgeries, lasting pain, or the death of a family member.

What Cases Like Yours Have Recovered

Our firm has recovered $30,500,000 for a man trapped by a defective garage door, and $1,250,000 in a medical malpractice case involving robotic-assisted surgery that resulted in internal bleeding and death. Our case results include many other outcomes. Past results cannot guarantee what any individual case will produce, because every claim turns on its own facts.

If a medical device has failed you or someone you love, we would like to help you find out why.

Contact an Indianapolis Defective Medical Device Lawyer at Christie Bell & Marshall

A failed medical device can mean more surgeries, months of recovery, and a manufacturer that insists the problem lies anywhere but its product. Christie Bell & Marshall has more than 40 years of Indiana trial experience and attorneys who spent years on the defense side of medical cases, and we know how these companies build their defenses.

You can talk with us at no cost, and there is no fee unless we win. Talk to our product liability team to start protecting the device, your records, and your deadlines.

FAQs About Indianapolis Defective Medical Device Claims

Can you sue a medical device company in Indiana?

Yes. Under the Indiana Product Liability Act, a manufacturer can be held responsible when a defective device injures a patient, whether the defect is in the manufacturing, the design, or the warnings. Some devices approved through the FDA’s premarket approval process have federal protection that limits certain claims, so the device’s regulatory history matters. Your implant card and operative report identify the exact product, so bring them to any meeting about your medical devices. Indiana lawyers who handle these claims start with those two records.

What should I do if I think my medical device is defective?

Keep all records of your surgery and the device, including any implant card. If the device is removed, ask that it be preserved rather than discarded, and do not send it back to the manufacturer. You can report the problem through the FDA’s MedWatch program, and you should talk with a lawyer before giving any statement to the manufacturer. Manufacturers sometimes ask patients or hospitals to return explanted medical devices. Indianapolis lawyers at CBM can answer those requests for you so the device stays in safe hands.

What qualifies as a defective medical device?

A device is defective if it was manufactured with a flaw, designed in a way that made it unreasonably dangerous, or sold without adequate warnings about its risks. A device can also be part of a malpractice claim if a provider chose, implanted, or monitored it negligently.

Is a device failure always the manufacturer’s fault?

No. Some failures come from how a device was implanted, adjusted, or monitored, which can make a surgeon or hospital responsible under Indiana’s Medical Malpractice Act. Many cases involve both a product claim and a malpractice claim, and each must be filed on its own timeline. Sorting out that split is a large part of the work in cases over failed medical devices. Indiana attorneys who know both product and malpractice law can run the two claims side by side.

How long do I have to file a defective medical device claim in Indiana?

Product liability claims generally must be filed within two years after the claim accrues and within ten years after the device was first delivered to its initial user. Claims against a doctor or hospital for related malpractice have a separate two-year deadline under the Medical Malpractice Act, and the general injury deadline appears in IC 34-11-2-4.

Indianapolis Office

951 N Delaware St Indianapolis, IN 46202
Phone: 317-488-5500